Antisemitism

The Canary in the Coalmine: Why Rising Antisemitism Signals Societal Decay

A clear-eyed look at the rise of antisemitism in America: what the FBI and ADL numbers actually show, why Jewish safety is an early warning for the whole country, and what taking that warning seriously requires.

Miners used to carry canaries underground because the bird would collapse from bad air before a man would. When the singing stopped, the shaft was already poisoned. The same logic has been applied, carefully and for a long time, to Jewish life. South Africa’s Chief Rabbi Warren Goldstein put it plainly in 2015: the condition of the Jews in a society is a test of whether that society is still safe. If they are thriving, the air is clear. If they are not, danger is already in the room, whether or not everyone else can smell it yet.

This is not a metaphor about Jewish fragility. It is a warning about everyone else. As the late Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks told the European Parliament in 2016, “The hate that begins with Jews never ends with Jews.” He was not asking Europe to do the Jews a favor. He was telling Europe that antisemitism is “the first symptom of a disease, the early warning sign of collective breakdown.”

America should listen. The rise of antisemitism in America is no longer a debate about vibes. It is in the official record.

What the official numbers actually say

Start with the crimes reported to police. In 2022, the FBI recorded 1,122 anti-Jewish hate crime incidents. In 2023 — the year of the Hamas-led massacre in Israel on October 7, and the year the American street and campus changed almost overnight — that number jumped to 1,832. The Department of Justice’s own summary of the 2023 data is blunt: there were 2,699 religion-based hate crime incidents, and more than half of them, 1,832, were driven by anti-Jewish bias.

The 2024 figures went higher still. The FBI’s Hate Crime Statistics for 2024 list 1,938 anti-Jewish incidents out of 2,783 religion-based incidents — about 70 percent of all religion-motivated hate crimes reported that year. In 2025 the count receded to 1,528 anti-Jewish incidents, still about 63 percent of religion-based hate crimes, and still among the highest totals on record. Overall hate crime incidents fell from 11,679 in 2024 to 10,881 in 2025. The decline is real. So is the plateau it landed on: well above the pre-October 7 baseline.

Now put those numbers next to the size of the community. Pew Research Center estimated in 2020 that Jews make up about 2.4 percent of the U.S. population, roughly 7.5 million people. A group that small accounting for the majority of religion-based hate crimes, year after year, is not a rounding error. It is a pattern.

Two cautions, because the record deserves precision. First, FBI figures only count crimes that law enforcement agencies report. They undercount, and they do not measure the slur in a hallway, the social exclusion, or the student who stops wearing a kippah. Second, they are not the same thing as the Anti-Defamation League’s annual Audit of Antisemitic Incidents, which includes criminal and non-criminal harassment, vandalism, and assault reported by victims, police, the press, and partner groups.

That broader audit is starker, and it tells the same story. The ADL recorded 8,873 incidents in 2023 and 9,354 in 2024 — the highest total in the 46 years it has kept the books, a 5 percent rise from an already record year, and an 893 percent increase over the prior decade. Campus incidents in 2024 hit 1,694, 84 percent higher than in 2023, and made up a larger share of the audit than in any previous year. In 2025 the audit fell 33 percent, to 6,274 incidents. That is still, by the ADL’s count, five times higher than a decade earlier, and it was the first year since 2019 in which Jews were murdered in antisemitic attacks in the United States. The heat came off the street in some places. The air did not clear.

After October 7, the excuse machine

October 7, 2023, was not a protest. It was a massacre. What followed in the United States was not ordinary “criticism of a government.” It was a permission structure. Jewish students were boxed out of common spaces. Synagogues and Jewish institutions took bomb threats. People were assaulted for looking Jewish or for attending a gathering to remember the dead. The ADL found that in 2024, for the first time in the audit’s history, a majority of incidents — 58 percent — contained elements related to Israel or Zionism.

You can oppose particular Israeli policies. Serious people do it every day, including in Israel. That is not what this is. Sacks drew the line in a classroom, and it still holds. He asked students whether they had a right to criticize their own government; they all said yes. He asked which of them believed their country had no right to exist; no one raised a hand. “Now you know the difference,” he told them.

The new packaging is “decolonization,” “resistance,” or “punching up.” The content is older: Jews as uniquely illegitimate, collectively guilty, and fair game. When a society starts treating the Jewish state as the one country that must be erased, and Jewish students as stand-ins for that country, it is not doing geopolitics. It is rehearsing a very old habit in a new dialect. I will take up the left- and right-wing versions of that habit in a later essay. The point here is simpler. A culture that cannot tell the difference between argument and elimination is already losing the plot.

Why the canary dies first

Antisemitism is useful to people who need a scapegoat. It collapses complicated failures — economic pain, lost wars, cultural panic, elite distrust — into a single, available enemy. Sacks again: it is “about people who cannot accept responsibility for their own failures and have instead to blame someone else.” Once that move is allowed, it does not stay contained. A politics that runs on collective blame will find new targets. A campus that cheers the erasure of one people will not become more careful with the next. A street that excuses violence as “context” will not stay limited to its first victims.

That is the canary’s function. Jews are a small, identifiable, often successful minority with a long memory and, in America, a high degree of public visibility. They are easy to mythologize and easy to isolate. If a country cannot protect them, it is already failing a more basic test: equal protection under the law, and the refusal to make any group pay for the world’s frustrations.

History is not a spreadsheet, and I will not pretend that every collapse begins the same way. But the sequence is familiar enough that we do not get to claim surprise. First the conspiracy stories. Then the vandalism and the boycotts. Then the assaults. Then the argument that the victims had it coming. By the time the rest of the society feels the heat, the warning has been sounding for years.

America is not 1930s Europe. Pretending otherwise is cheap panic, and Sacks himself rejected that comparison. It is also cheap comfort to act as if the only two options are “the 1930s” or “nothing to see.” The 2025 dip in reported incidents is not a return to normal. It is a slightly quieter alarm.

What taking the warning seriously looks like

If you are waiting for a more convenient time to care, you have already decided not to. The work is ordinary, and it is public.

Tell the truth about the numbers, even when they complicate a political story you like. Demand that schools and employers enforce the same rules for Jewish students and staff that they would enforce for anyone else. Distinguish criticism of policy from the denial of Jewish peoplehood. Show up for your Jewish neighbors — at a synagogue event, a campus hearing, or simply when a lie goes unchallenged in a group chat.

I wrote a book about this because a news cycle is not an argument, and a slogan is not a history. If you want the longer case, it is in Reflections on the Rise of Antisemitism in America. You can also meet the rest of the work on this site — the books, the commentary, and the systems I teach for people who want to build independently.

None of that replaces the first duty, which is simpler: when the canary goes quiet, you do not negotiate with the gas. You clear the mine. Truth still needs defenders. Be one.

Sources

Free Call The Book